There’s a French nursery rhyme that goes: “La peinture à l’huile c’est bien difficile, mais c’est bien plus beau que la peinture à l’eau.” – This translates to: Oil painting is very difficult, but it is much prettier than water paint – In which case “water paint” could be interpreted as watercolours or again, water soluble paint, like acrylic.
I don’t know how much this nursery rhyme has contributed to the belief that oil painting is hard but there sure seem to be a lot of people that think so – I met countless of acrylic painters that say that they can’t do oils to save their lives – Well if you are one of those folks, it might interest you to know that I can’t paint in acrylic to save my life –I bet you didn’t suspect me to say that but there, I said it.
So is oil more difficult than acrylic, really? I think it is more a matter of personality. I find that acrylic dries too fast – Yes I know, there’s some medium you can mix with acrylic paint to slow down its drying process but that still dries too fast for my tastes – You see, I like to play with the paint, mix the colours on the canvas. I’m quite an Introvert type of person, my best virtues are patience and persistence, and according to some cognitive tests I undergone a couple years ago, it does indeed seem that my brain is strongly wired to “favour precision over rapidity of execution”.
I used to think that people that don’t have the patience to sit still and do only one thing for several hours non stop until it’s completed, don’t have what it takes to do a decent painting or drawing – But that has changed when I met Guy, the painting teacher at one of the community centre where I teach drawing classes. Guy is an Extrovert, very out going, generous and expressive person – Guy teaches both acrylic and oils but says he prefers acrylics because he doesn’t like waiting 3 or 4 days for the paint to dry. He says: “Things have got to get going with me, continuously.”
He also told me that sometimes his oil students are making him impatient because they spend a long time painting their sky, chitchatting with each other, then get up, grab a cup of coffee, chitchat some more, then get back into class and continue working slowly on their skies – Guy said: “That takes forever and ever, my gosh it’s driving me crazy!” – That made me chuckle – I realized that his oil students must alienate him just as much as those of my students that hurry to complete their drawings alienate me.
Which medium is better suited for you? If you like to work slowly, focussing on one thing at a time, if you like to experiment, play with colours on the canvas and don’t mind waiting a long time before seeing some results, oil may just be the perfect medium for you – On the other hand, action going, multi tasking, spontaneous types will very much prefer acrylics – This said however, it doesn’t solve the problem of beginner painters who have not yet gained the experience and confidence in their skill to work fast – Because acrylic paint dries fast, beginners might find it disabling. So please, do yourself a favour and give oils a chance.